How to Make Cottage Cheese with Raw Milk


Charlotte in front, directly behind is her calf Elle (now full grown), and daughter Fern.

This article is for those of you with access to the real deal…raw, unpasteurized, un-homogenized straight from the cow – milk.

In a nut shell, pasteurized milk has been heated to kill live enzymes plus good, possibly bad, bacteria to increase its shelf life. Homogenized milk has been essentially, blasted through a screen to break up the milk molecules to keep them from separating into cream-on-top milk, and to mix all the dead enzymes and bacteria up so they don’t sink to the bottom and make the milk unattractive to drink.

I could talk about the benefits of raw milk verses processed milk literally until the cows come home but this is an article about how to make cottage cheese. If you continue reading with the intentions of not making cottage cheese, I guarantee you will still learn something you didn’t know.

At Kumu Aina, we have currently three milking cows on the farm and one heifer. A heifer is a bovine who hasn’t had a calf, once they have calved you can officially call them a cow.

Our bovines eat nothing but elephant grass, tree leaves and tropical fruit. They never get grain so they are entirely grass-fed. In addition, we don’t give them antibiotics, growth hormones or rBGH (a hormone to increase milk production). They are family cows.


Salad with fresh cottage cheese.

My cheese making experience is limited to raw milk and I have never tried to make dairy products with anything else.

Having said that, there is not a lot of recipes out there for using strictly raw milk. So, I naturally follow pasteurized milk recipes and make adjustments using raw milk.

Cottage cheese is one of the easiest cheeses to make. One adjustment I make is I do not add rennet. Rennet is a natural additive and you can use animal rennet or vegetarian rennet. They both work fine. I don’t recommend using rennet for cottage cheese because it tends to make the cottage cheese squeak when you eat it and you don’t need it.

Typically, you don’t use fresh milk to make cottage cheese. Use milk that is on the verge of culturing. By the way, raw milk doesn’t go bad or putrefy like store-bought milk, it cultures and still tastes good and is edible.

When I am arranging my milk, I sort the freshest stuff to the week old. It tends to get away from you, if you have an abundance. It’s a good way to use week old milk, which by the way, still tastes good and is not bad.

To make cottage cheese all you need to do is skim the cream off a gallon of milk using a stainless-steel spoon. Some cream will remain, and you can skim the rest off later. Cream cultures faster then milk, so I take it off. You can use the cream to make other things like butter or you can add it back into the cottage cheese later.

Start by pouring the skimmed milk into a stainless steel stock pot.

cottage cheese2_lr

Cubed curd.

If you don’t have a culture to add, you can proceed in two ways. One, you can heat the milk up to 86 degrees while stirring it often, cover it, and then set it aside. In the second method, just set it aside, no heating.

Eighty-six to ninty degrees is the perfect temperature for milk to grow culture without killing any existing cultures. Where does culture come from in raw milk? Well, the milk for one and the air for another. Set the pot in an out of the way corner and cover with a clean kitchen towel and wait for a day or two. Either method works and comes up with the same result – the heated method a little faster. Both turn into a yogurt-like consistency product before you continue to the next step.

If you also make raw-cultured, butter at home, you can use the buttermilk as a culture. If you add 2 tablespoons of buttermilk to a gallon of milk it will culture the next day.

2014-04-03 11.23.09

To know when to proceed, the “milk” will pull off the side of the pot when you tilt the pot. It will look like jello or yogurt. At this point, you may see a small bit of cream still on the top of your milk, you can skim it off with a spoon. You can use this cream later to make butter or add it back into the cottage cheese after you heat it and drain it.


Next, take a long knife, I usually use a bread knife, and cut the curd into one inch squares going both front to back and side to side so it looks like a checkerboard. Then cut diagonally tilting the knife as to cut the curds longways.

When you are done you will have squares of “yogurt” like cubes. You can’t really mess this up but take your time and be gentle.





Curds start looking like cottage cheese.

With the cubes, still in the stock pot, place it over a medium-low heat and stir gently every so often. You will now see the beautiful cubes of white cultured milk. Heat to only 104 °F if you are on a raw animal foods diet and up to 115-120 °F if not. Stir more often as the heat increases to the desired temperature.

I like to heat mine to 104 degrees and then shut it off. Then I let it rest for 10 minutes and stir it again. Stirring releases the whey. I stir mine until I am happy with the look and texture.

In addition, mesophilic culture is still present at 104 degrees. I’m not sure if this matters, but I like the fact that I still have this additional culture present in my cheese. You can save a quart of the whey, containing the mesophilic culture, in the refrigerator and pour a pint into your milk for your next batch prior to setting it out to increase the cultures. This also helps speed up the process.

At this point, those cubes will have the look of cottage cheese curds. The hotter the water the more solid or harder the curds become and the more whey is released. So it’s a matter of preference. Your final result is still considered a raw food (if you keep the temperature under 104 °F).

Now your curds will be floating in whey. Line a colander with cheese cloth for draining. I always catch the whey. So many uses! Mostly we use it in place of water in bread making and it makes the bread taste like sour-dough bread. I also feed it to my chickens and pigs. Don’t give it to your dog in large quantities though because it will give them diarrhea in the middle of the night. A few tablespoons in their dry kibble will be fine. You can also pour it on plants or trees to introduce probiotics to the soil among other good things. Use it to lacto-ferment vegetables. Full of protein and minerals.

cottage cheese_lr

Ready to eat.

Let your curds drain for at least 20 minutes. Then put them in a mixing bowl to break up into smaller curds. You can add salt if you like or add the cream back in that you skimmed off. One gallon should make about a quart of cheese.

It’s basically ready to eat. I put it in a quart jar and refrigerate.

You can put it in a lot of dishes, even pastas like lasagna. I especially like to add cut up papaya, pineapple, or mango for an amazing cool snack or breakfast. I also use it to make cheesecake. Any way you use it, it is absolutely delicious.



Related posts you'll like:

11 thoughts on “How to Make Cottage Cheese with Raw Milk

  1. Have you ever had the curd break when you started to heat the curd? I’ve been making for years and this year it just keeps falling apart. Driving me nuts. Even when I use rennet the curd breaks.

  2. Hope you had a blessed Christmas! I bookmarked this recipe awhile back knowing I could try it when I visit my parents in the country. How long will it keep in the fridge? Also, this might be a stupid question, but I have only ever made heated cottage cheese in small quantities because I live in a high-rise condo. Here I have the time and the space to try without heating. It is winter, although one of the mildest in many years. Will it still get to 86 degrees? best place to let sit: sunroom off the kitchen, kitchen counter or basement? Thank you.

    • Well, I’d be interested in knowing how it turns out. It may just take longer to make. You might try keeping it inn a warm water bath in a cooler to keep it warm and to make it faster. I’d heat it up first to 86 then put it in 86 degree water bath and add hot water as needed. Or experiment and leave it out on counter for a few days.

  3. Ok so I tried it! It does taste a little sour. Is it supposed to taste a little sour? The raw milk was about three to four weeks old. It smelled fine though I didn’t taste it. The cottage cheese sat for two days on the stove as it’s been hot here; about 82- 84 degree days. When I came to work with it this morning, the “curd” had formed and sunk to the bottom of the whey. I heated it, probably a little too much as I didn’t have a thermometer, then drained it. The curds look perfect and the whey separated out, but they taste a little sour!! Do you think the milk may have gotten too far past? I know all the way from HI this isn’t going to be easy to tell me what happened!! Your directions were great and so easy. Even if this isn’t right … yet… I can’t wait to try it again!! Thanks!!

    • What goes in, is what comes out. Three to four week old milk is going to be sour. If you don’t have a thermometer, just test with your finger. It should feel slightly warm considering your body is 98.6 degrees. Most recipe books will tell you to use the freshest milk. This recipe is good because you don’t have to use the freshest but you can’t use milk that is way over what would be considered drinkable. Ten days old is probably the max that I would use. Good luck with your cheese making Sally. I’m sure the next time will be better!

  4. I tried this and it worked great up to the point where you heat the curds you have cut to separate the whey.

    I had it on high heat when I started to warm it went to grab my recipe and then realized it said low-medium heat.

    What I ended up with looked like melted mozzarella cheese. After I hung it to drain the whey the end product tastes delicious. But it also tastes like mozzarella cheese.

    What did I make?

    I see how I “messed” up in getting cottage cheese. Just wondering if you know what I did make. It still tastes great. The best cheese I’ve had in a long time.

    • You may have heated the cheese too fast and too hot. I call that spontaneous mozzarella cheese! Its happened to me before. Just keep your eye on the temp. and stir it so it heats evenly. Sounds like you were happy with the results. Keep on improving on your technique. Aloha.

      • Thanks! Thats is what I did. It does taste like the best most flavorful mozzarella I’ve ever had. It was the first time I ever made any kind of Cheese. Was super excited to just see what happened. 🙂

Let us know what you think